With regards to the RTLinux technology patent recently received by Victor Yodaiken (see related story: RTLinux is Patented?), Graham Lea writes in The Register . . .

“A tricky situation has arisen over a Linux patent (US: 5,995,745) obtained by Victor Yodaiken of Real-Time Linux. Although he intends that users of RTLinux, as well as Linux users who label their application as being compatible with RTLinux and who release them under GPL will not have to pay royalties, it is a narrow path that he is walking.”

“Already there are questions as to what the situation will be for non-Linux free products like BSD and Hurd. Those who wish to use his patent in commercial systems will have to pay a royalty. Yodaiken is apparently working out details with Linux International and Linus Torvalds.”

“But there is another issue, raised by Greg Aharonian in his Patnews: he calls the patent 'of low quality', suggests that 'this patent wasn't validly sought', and draws attention to the considerable inadequacy of the prior art. Yodaiken quotes just four other patents and a paper on MERT, a Unix time-sharing system described in 1978 . . . there have been thousands of other papers on the subject, and hundreds of patents, all of which appear to add up to the inevitable conclusion that the patent was not examined properly by the highly inadequate US patent office.”

* Read full story *

 
This article was originally published on LinuxDevices.com and has been donated to the open source community by QuinStreet Inc. Please visit LinuxToday.com for up-to-date news and articles about Linux and open source.